Skip to content
The Catholic Leader
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
The Catholic Leader
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion Letters

Criticism of US Action Too Harsh

byStaff writers
9 December 2001
Reading Time: 2 mins read
AA
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

I WISH to take issue with the Australian Catholic Social Justice Council’s (ACSJC) claim (CL 25/11/01) that the allied assault in Afghanistan meets ‘only one of the Church’s six just war criteria’.

The ACSJC does concede that some response to the attacks of September 11 ‘was legitimate self defence’ but does not recognise the authority of the allied grouping which ordered the military action. Astonishingly, the ACSJC claims ‘that the appropriate body to do this was the UN Security Council’.

One only has to remember the appalling performances of the UN in the recent conflicts in Rwanda and in the former Yugoslavia to understand why the US and its allies would refuse to deal with it.

The third point made by the ACSJC is that the allied attack on Afghanistan was not taken ‘as a last resort after all non-violent means were exhausted’. One wonders what ‘non-violent means’ would have had a hope of success.

Also, while months and perhaps years passed using these ‘non-violent means’, would bin Laden and his cohorts sit quietly twiddling their thumbs? Surely the threat of further terrorist attacks on a massive scale necessitated an urgent response?

The ACSJC then goes on to criticise the allies for their failure to ensure ‘a reasonable chance of success’. This seems to be especially harsh. Sure bin Laden (at the time of writing) has not been captured. However, the allies are certainly doing their best to apprehend him and they have at least broken the power of the Taliban, one of the most oppressive regimes known to the modern world.

On the issue of proportionality, there is room for debate. Certainly, in any conflict, there is the risk of widespread suffering and death and it is obvious that many Muslims have been angered by the attack on Afghanistan.

However, with bin Laden urging Muslims to kill Christians and Westerners wherever they find them, there is the counter-balancing risk that unless he is brought down – and very soon – the rift between Muslims and Christians will become a chasm. Bin Laden is doing his best to widen the Afghan conflict into a worldwide struggle for supremacy between East and West.

Finally, the ACSJC believes the allies have not done enough ‘to guarantee adequate protection for civilians’. In this I have to agree. The use of cluster bombs – many of which fail to explode on impact – is a tactic which puts civilians at risk even years after a conflict has ceased.

This, of course, brings us back to the issue of proportionality. Given the nature of the issues involved, do the negative aspects of the Afghan campaign outweigh the apparent need to deal firmly and decisively with ruthless terrorism?

Related Stories

‘We must act now’ – Caritas Australia chief says Ethiopian food crisis is acute

Vote over role of women disrupts Plenary Council assembly

Pope Francis condemns Independence Day parade attack and calls for end of violence

While there is no easy answer to this question, I have no doubt that the ACSJC is far too harsh in its criticism of the US and its allies.

ROBERT LEACH Noosaville, Qld

ShareTweet
Previous Post

SHADOW MAGIC

Next Post

Flower Power Helps Babies

Staff writers

Related Posts

Caritas Australia Richard Landels

‘We must act now’ – Caritas Australia chief says Ethiopian food crisis is acute

6 July 2022
Plenary Council assembly reaches decision day about the Church role of women
News

Vote over role of women disrupts Plenary Council assembly

6 July 2022
Mazur/catholicnews.org.uk.
World

Pope Francis condemns Independence Day parade attack and calls for end of violence

6 July 2022
Next Post

Flower Power Helps Babies

Bill Backdown

Jewish Scriptures and Christianity

Popular News

  • Plenary Council assembly reaches decision day about the Church role of women

    Vote over role of women disrupts Plenary Council assembly

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Plenary Council assembly reaches decision day about the Church role of women

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Plans for indigenous elements, memorials to trauma, to complement Catholic liturgy

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Mass with signs of indigenous respect launch historic Plenary Council assembly

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Called to share the message of Jesus at mission school

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Search our job finder
No Result
View All Result

Latest News

Caritas Australia Richard Landels

‘We must act now’ – Caritas Australia chief says Ethiopian food crisis is acute

by Hannah Kennelly
6 July 2022
0

RITAS Australia chief executive officer Kirsty Robertson has called for an immediate response for ugent famine prevention...

Plenary Council assembly reaches decision day about the Church role of women

Vote over role of women disrupts Plenary Council assembly

6 July 2022
Mazur/catholicnews.org.uk.

Pope Francis condemns Independence Day parade attack and calls for end of violence

6 July 2022
Plenary Council assembly reaches decision day about the Church role of women

Plenary Council assembly reaches decision day about the Church role of women

6 July 2022
‘For the moment, no,’ – Pope Francis dismisses resignation rumours in wide-ranging interview

‘For the moment, no,’ – Pope Francis dismisses resignation rumours in wide-ranging interview

5 July 2022

Never miss a story. Sign up to the Weekly Round-Up
eNewsletter now to receive headlines directly in your email.

Sign up to eNews
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe

The Catholic Leader is an Australian award-winning Catholic newspaper that has been published by the Archdiocese of Brisbane since 1929. Our journalism seeks to provide a full, accurate and balanced Catholic perspective of local, national and international news while upholding the dignity of the human person.

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader
Accessibility Information | Privacy Policy | Archdiocese of Brisbane

The Catholic Leader acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the First Peoples of this country and especially acknowledge the traditional owners on whose lands we live and work throughout the Catholic Archdiocese of Brisbane.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader

0
    0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyChoose another Subscription
    Continue Shopping