A Coptic Catholic bishop who served as a member of the assembly that drafted Egypt’s 2012 constitution said his country would not have a civil war, and foreign powers – including the United Nations– should not interfere. In a wide-ranging interview with Arab West Report, Bishop Youhanna Golta of Alexandria, Egypt, also said people must view Egypt as a whole and not just be concerned about Coptic Christians. He discussed the history of Islam and asked for patience for Egyptian democracy, reminding people that European democracy took four centuries to evolve, and Egyptians have only had two or three years. “Civil war is when a part of the country turns against the other part. This is not the case in Egypt,” the bishop said on August 15, the day after more than 600 people were killed and several thousand injured after a police crackdown on people protesting the ousting of former President Mohammed Morsi. “In Egypt, the people are united against a certain group that doesn’t represent more than 2 per cent of the country,” he said, referring to extremists within the Muslim Brotherhood, to which Morsi belongs. “This cannot be called a civil war; these are called (acts of) terrorism. “With respect to the burning of the churches, I said today in the Akhbar newspaper that ‘burning of the churches makes us (Christians) proud, because we are contributing to the liberation of Egypt’.” Some Egyptian media published a list of all the Christian buildings and residences that had been burned in recent months. Church leaders condemned the attacks and, after the August 14 violence, called off vigil services for the August 15 feast of the Assumption. Arab West Report is an online magazine dedicated to fostering greater understanding and tolerance between Arab and Western cultures. The interview with Bishop Golta was reprinted on the website of the Oasis Center, which Milan Cardinal Angelo Scola established to promote Christian-Muslim dialogue. Most of Bishop Golta’s interview with Arab West Report was conducted August 13 and, in it, the bishop called discrimination against Christians an “ideological and strategic mistake by extremist groups.” “There is no street or alley in Egypt that does not have both Muslims and Christians living together,” he said. “It is impossible that Egypt gets divided. Egyptians are indivisible.” He said historically, Islam was “the only religion that did not plan on eliminating other people.” “Occupiers usually requested the occupied people convert their religions to those of their occupiers,” he said. “Muslims did not do that. They (extremists) are deleting this icon in Islamic history.” The bishop rejected the term “Coptic issues,” used to refer to issues that concern Egypt’s Christians. “We don’t have Coptic issues, we have Egyptian issues,” the bishop said. “That Copts are granted their rights while Muslims are deprived of them is not acceptable to me and indeed impossible to achieve. “That the Copts undergo development while the Muslims live miserably is unacceptable and will not happen. “We both rise and develop together or not. I am a believing Christian and I hope to die as a Christian, but Muslims face more injustice than Christians. “The rate of poverty and unemployment among Muslims is higher than that the average rate. Here the view must be to Egypt as a whole and not to Copts only.” He called for “separation of religion and state, but not separating religion from society.” “There is a difference. I am for having a state whose laws are civic laws, but we must also nourish society with the spirit of religion and ethics,” he said. Responding to a question about whether a third party should facilitate dialogue among Egyptians, Bishop Golta responded, “Never. The (European Union) and US should never intervene,” then added the United Nations to his response. “They have the money but not the rational or emotional capacity,” he said. “The EU and the US only care about their interests. We are an impoverished, humiliated, ignorant, marginalised, beastly people in their views. “No third party should intervene. “If we didn’t know how to resolve our issues on our own, then we should not deserve to live.” CNS
The Catholic Leader is an Australian award-winning Catholic newspaper that has been published by the Archdiocese of Brisbane since 1929. Our journalism seeks to provide a full, accurate and balanced Catholic perspective of local, national and international news while upholding the dignity of the human person.
The Catholic Leader acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the First Peoples of this country and especially acknowledge the traditional owners on whose lands we live and work throughout the Catholic Archdiocese of Brisbane.