Skip to content
The Catholic Leader
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
The Catholic Leader
No Result
View All Result
Home News Australia

Ethics of the investigation into prolific Brisbane sperm donor explained

byEmilie Ng
15 December 2020
Reading Time: 5 mins read
AA
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Ethics: Fr Kevin McGovern said the case of a man, who reportedly fathered 23 children in one year through private sperm donations and registered clinics, raised serious ethical questions.

A CATHOLIC priest who helped write the ethical guidelines on assisted reproductive technology said the actions of a sperm donor being investigated for fathering 23 children were illegal and unethical.

Fr Kevin McGovern, who is based in Victoria, was a member of Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Working Committee that wrote the national ethical guidelines on the use of assisted reproductive technology and was released in 2017 for the Australian Government’s National Health and Medical Research Council.

The guidelines offer standards on the use, donation and storage of gametes, the medical term for sperm and egg cells, including minimising the number of families created through “donated gamete treatment programs” such as in vitro fertilisation.

The guidelines were established in lieu of some states and territories not having legislation about assisted reproductive technology.

Fr McGovern said the case of a man, who reportedly fathered 23 children in one year through private sperm donations and registered clinics, raised serious ethical questions.

The man is being investigated by the Victorian Assisted Reproductive Authority (VARTA) for exceeding the limit of families that can be formed through one donor’s donations.

In Victoria, where some of the man’s sperm was being used, a donor can only form up to 10 families, including what they create with their partner.

This legislation enforces section 5.3.2 of the national guidelines, which states that clinics “must take all reasonable steps to minimise the number of families created through donated gamete treatment programs”.

A breach of this guideline would cause “the risk a person born from donor gametes inadvertently having a sexual relationship with a close genetic relative”.

Fr McGovern said registered fertility clinics required donors to abide by these guidelines.

Related Stories

Brisbane adoration community sees surge in adorers, more needed

Brisbane gets small morning reprieve to inspect damages after 72 hours hard rain

Queensland priest brought Church wisdom to Australian health ethics for nine years

“This man has obviously gotten around that by donating directly to women who have inseminated themselves,” he said.

“What he’s done is illegal in Victoria and unethical.

“He has possibly been motivated by a sense of concern for women, possibly motivated a bit by a sense of feeling ‘I’m doing something special’.

“The other issue here is that not every donor-inseminated child is made aware of their origin by their parents.”

Given that 23 children in the community could trace the sperm donor as their biological father, Fr McGovern strongly advised that all children created with the man’s sperm be told of how they were conceived.

“In this situation in particular they do need to know, they need to minimise the risk that they’ll end up finding a half-sibling,” he said.

“It is important the children are told early because if it’s concealed from it and they find out later in life, it can really be quite damaging and can really threaten their sense of self.”

Read more about the Catholic Church and IVF: Catholic ethicist says some fertility clinics misleading desperate couples with false IVF success rates

Uncertain future of human life

The Catholic Church teaches IVF to be immoral because it disassociates the procreative act with the sexual act.

The Church also opposes IVF for the dilemma that occurs when creating human embryos, which is that clinics usually fertilise eggs in excess of what can be safely re-implanted into a woman for pregnancy.

This means that some embryos would almost certainly never be used or needed by a couple, so they are either stored indefinitely, used in medical research or destroyed.

Regarding the VARTA investigation, one media outlet reported at least one couple was told they could not use embryos in storage created with the man’s sperm because of the Victorian law around the number of families created by one donor.

The Catholic Church opposes embryos used for research but does not have a strong teaching against embryo adoption.

Dignitas Personae, the Vatican’s instruction on certain bioethical questions, described embryo adoption as “praiseworthy with regard to the intention of respecting and defending human life” but presented “various problems”.

Fr McGovern said he had spoken with many couples about the future of their excess embryos.

Couples considered it a deeply difficult decision because Fr McGovern said they truly believed their excess embryos were their children.

“I can remember one woman who said to me, what am I going to do about my three babies?” he said.

“It’s probably one of the differences between the sections of the community that are involved in termination, where they would tend to deny the fact that this is a human life, a human being, a child.

“In the fertility clinics, everyone is very clear that this is a child.”

Although he is not up to date with current figures, Fr McGovern’s last check on the number of cryogenically preserved embryos in Australia came to 50,000 to 60,000.

He said the Catholic Church once advised for the removal of frozen embryos before “allowing them to succumb” but more recent statements suggested embryos should be cryogenically preserved “as long as is possible in the hope that something might eventually be found for them”.

“And there’s really no solution to that dilemma,” he said.

“There are problems that just don’t have solutions.”

MORE STORIES ON LIFE ETHICS:

  • The transgender phenomenon: Three Catholic ethicists widen the debate
  • Catholic priest based in Melbourne reflects on euthanasia bill: “Please pray for us in Victoria”

ShareTweet
Previous Post

Children’s book on screen time a novel idea for concerned parents

Next Post

Special Christmas newspapers are arriving at Brisbane parishes this week

Emilie Ng

Emilie Ng is a Brisbane-based journalist for The Catholic Leader.

Related Posts

A Holy Hour before the Blessed Sacrament
QLD

Brisbane adoration community sees surge in adorers, more needed

31 March 2022
Deluge: Flood waters at The Wheel of Brisbane at Southbank Parklands. Photos: Robert Falzon / Facebook
QLD

Brisbane gets small morning reprieve to inspect damages after 72 hours hard rain

28 February 2022
Thinking ahead: Developments in the area of artificial intelligence is one of three key areas Fr Kevin MGovern is most interested in following in relation to health ethics debates.
People

Queensland priest brought Church wisdom to Australian health ethics for nine years

9 February 2022
Next Post

Special Christmas newspapers are arriving at Brisbane parishes this week

Brisbane Courage director warns against conversion therapy bill

Person sits inside an empty church

Parishes given option to seat at full capacity for Christmas Masses

Popular News

  • Plans for indigenous elements, memorials to trauma, to complement Catholic liturgy

    Plans for indigenous elements, memorials to trauma, to complement Catholic liturgy

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Mass with signs of indigenous respect launch historic Plenary Council assembly

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • ‘For the moment, no,’ – Pope Francis dismisses resignation rumours in wide-ranging interview

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Called to share the message of Jesus at mission school

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Future First Nations teachers honoured with Rome scholarship

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Search our job finder
No Result
View All Result

Latest News

‘For the moment, no,’ – Pope Francis dismisses resignation rumours in wide-ranging interview
Vatican

‘For the moment, no,’ – Pope Francis dismisses resignation rumours in wide-ranging interview

by Catholic News Agency
5 July 2022
0

POPE Francis has said he has no plans to resign soon and that his knee injury is...

Plans for indigenous elements, memorials to trauma, to complement Catholic liturgy

Plans for indigenous elements, memorials to trauma, to complement Catholic liturgy

5 July 2022
Spirit of Mission: A group of young people including university students, seminarians and ministry workers present at the Xavier School of Mission held June 20 to 24. The mission school hosted guest speakers and workshops to encourage people to go out and proclaim the Word. Photo: Joe Higgins

Called to share the message of Jesus at mission school

4 July 2022
Cathedral green packed with families for festival day

Cathedral green packed with families for festival day

4 July 2022
Fr Mike Schmitz’s next podcast Catechism in a Year starts New Year’s Day

Fr Mike Schmitz’s next podcast Catechism in a Year starts New Year’s Day

4 July 2022

Never miss a story. Sign up to the Weekly Round-Up
eNewsletter now to receive headlines directly in your email.

Sign up to eNews
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe

The Catholic Leader is an Australian award-winning Catholic newspaper that has been published by the Archdiocese of Brisbane since 1929. Our journalism seeks to provide a full, accurate and balanced Catholic perspective of local, national and international news while upholding the dignity of the human person.

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader
Accessibility Information | Privacy Policy | Archdiocese of Brisbane

The Catholic Leader acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the First Peoples of this country and especially acknowledge the traditional owners on whose lands we live and work throughout the Catholic Archdiocese of Brisbane.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader

0
    0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyChoose another Subscription
    Continue Shopping