Skip to content
The Catholic Leader
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
The Catholic Leader
No Result
View All Result
Home Life Faith

Q&A – Can we trust the Gospels?

byGuest Contributor
24 September 2021
Reading Time: 5 mins read
AA
Gospel narratives: Fr John Flader discusses the accuracy of the Gospels. Photo: CNS

Gospel narratives: Fr John Flader discusses the accuracy of the Gospels. Photo: CNS

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Fr John Flader

In reading the Gospels I come across different accounts of the same event, and sometimes there are discrepancies between them. Can we trust the truthfulness of the Gospels when such obvious differences appear?

THE discrepancies, rather than being proof that the Gospels are not faithful to the events as they occurred, are rather evidence for their authenticity and truthfulness.

But let me explain.

If the accounts of the same event were all identical to each other, it could be questioned whether the writers had conspired among themselves in writing them.

This in turn could cast doubts about whether the events were reported truthfully, or whether they were possibly fabricated.

Alternatively, it could be thought that there was really only one eye-witness to the events, which were written down by one evangelist and copied by the others.

If, however, there are slight differences in them, it is what one would expect when different people witness the same event and record later what they remembered.

We see this often when a group of people who have witnessed the same event get together to relate what they saw.

They all agree on the basic facts, but they remember different details and they may disagree on some of them.

Related Stories

Murdered Nigerians found suffering at foot of cross, bishop says at funeral

Telling stories and praying together at the heart of Catholic Refugee Week event

Rain or shine, Logan deanery brings families together at festival day

In any case, while there are some differences among the Gospel accounts, usually in minor details, what is remarkable is that there is substantial agreement among them in all the important matters.

Let us look at some examples. 

The Centurion

Centurion: Paolo Veronese's Renaissance depiction of Jesus and the Centurion.
Centurion: Paolo Veronese’s Renaissance depiction of Jesus and the Centurion.

We can begin with the account of the healing of the servant of a centurion.

Matthew relates that it was the centurion himself who begged Jesus to heal his servant (cf. Mt 8:5-13), whereas Luke says that the centurion sent elders of the Jews to ask for the healing (cf. Lk 7:1-10).

This is a very small detail and the explanation is simple.

In both cases it was the centurion who asked Jesus to do the healing.

Whether he did it in person or through others, he was the one who asked for it.

What is more, both Gospels agree on other significant details – that the request was made in Capernaum, that the centurion said that he was unworthy for Jesus to come under his roof, that Jesus said that not even in Israel had he found such faith, etc.

Casting out the demons

Early depiction: Mosaic of the exorcism of the Gerasene demoniac from the Basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo in Ravenna, dating to the sixth century AD.
Early depiction: Mosaic of the exorcism of the Gerasene demoniac from the Basilica of Sant’Apollinare Nuovo in Ravenna, dating to the sixth century AD.

Another example is the casting of demons into a herd of swine.

Matthew said the event took place in the country of the Gadarenes (cf. Mt 8:28-34) while Mark and Luke said it happened in the country of the Gerasenes (cf. Mk 5:1-20, Lk 8:26-39).

What is important is that the towns of Gadara and Gerasa were close to one another in the Decapolis region to the East of the Sea of Galilee.

The people of that area were not Jews and hence could raise pigs, a meat not eaten by the Jews.

Since the miracle did not take place in the town itself but in the countryside, where the swine were feeding, that two of the evangelists called the area that of the Gerasenes and the other that of the Gadarenes is a very small matter.

Another discrepancy in this same account is that Matthew said there were two demoniacs, while Mark and Luke said there was only one.

All three, however, agree that there were many demons in the man, or men, that they were fierce and powerful, and that the demons were cast into a large herd of pigs, which rushed down the steep bank into the sea.

These were the important details.

As regards whether there was one demoniac or two, we should take into account that it is most likely that Matthew, being an apostle, was an eye-witness to the event, while Mark and Luke may have heard of it later from the apostles.

The genealogy of Christ

An important discrepancy comes in the genealogies of Christ in the Gospels of Matthew and Luke (cf. Mt 1:1-17, Lk 3:23-38).

There are many differences in the names, especially from King David on.

A number of explanations have been given, a very plausible one being that one genealogy traces Jesus’ family tree through Mary’s line and the other through that of Joseph.

I dealt with this matter in my book Question Time 4, q. 459.

The Last Supper

Finally, another significant difference among the Gospels regards whether the Last Supper was held in the celebration of the Passover, as Matthew, Mark and Luke attest, or whether it was done the night before the Passover, as John wrote.

This question too I have discussed, in Question Time 3, q. 346.

ShareTweet
Previous Post

Vatican official decries Australia’s nuclear submarine program

Next Post

Share God’s love, don’t just lament lack of faith, Pope Francis says

Guest Contributor

Related Posts

Murdered Nigerians found suffering at foot of cross, bishop says at funeral
World

Murdered Nigerians found suffering at foot of cross, bishop says at funeral

21 June 2022
United Nations nuncio joins others in calling for end to hostilities in Ukraine
Australia

Telling stories and praying together at the heart of Catholic Refugee Week event

15 June 2022
Rain or shine, Logan deanery brings families together at festival day
QLD

Rain or shine, Logan deanery brings families together at festival day

7 June 2022
Next Post
Share God’s love, don’t just lament lack of faith, Pope Francis says

Share God's love, don't just lament lack of faith, Pope Francis says

Enthusiastic faith: Hundreds of young people are getting to know God at Ignite Youth conference.

Hundreds adore and grow closer to Jesus at Ignite Youth conference

Anniversary: The Sisters of St Paul de Chartres are celebrating their 325th anniversary all around the world.

‘Daring’ Sisters celebrate congregation’s 325 year history

Popular News

  • Performer: Liza is a trained gymnast and contortionist and has enjoyed performing at St Eugene College.

    Young Ukrainian performer settles into new life in Brisbane school

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Abdallah family deliver powerful Vatican speech

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Christianity still top, but numbers decline amidst a secular shift

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Pope Francis asks for prayers after 50 migrants found dead in Texas trailer truck

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Federal and state parliamentarians encourage pro-life Queenslanders at March for Life rally

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Search our job finder
No Result
View All Result

Latest News

Performer: Liza is a trained gymnast and contortionist and has enjoyed performing at St Eugene College.
Education

Young Ukrainian performer settles into new life in Brisbane school

by Hannah Kennelly
29 June 2022
0

LIZA fled the war in Ukraine with her mother and nothing but a single bag. The St...

Secret baptisms show how Christians still persecuted worldwide

Secret baptisms show how Christians still persecuted worldwide

29 June 2022
Tragedy: Debra Ponce, left, and Angelita Olvera of San Antonio mourn near the scene where dozens of immigrants were found dead inside a trailer truck a day earlier on June 28. Photo: CNS

Pope Francis asks for prayers after 50 migrants found dead in Texas trailer truck

29 June 2022
Mary Mother of Mercy Church

Christianity still top, but numbers decline amidst a secular shift

28 June 2022
Q&A – Who is the little-known patron saint of the Swiss Guard?

Q&A – Who is the little-known patron saint of the Swiss Guard?

27 June 2022

Never miss a story. Sign up to the Weekly Round-Up
eNewsletter now to receive headlines directly in your email.

Sign up to eNews
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe

The Catholic Leader is an Australian award-winning Catholic newspaper that has been published by the Archdiocese of Brisbane since 1929. Our journalism seeks to provide a full, accurate and balanced Catholic perspective of local, national and international news while upholding the dignity of the human person.

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader
Accessibility Information | Privacy Policy | Archdiocese of Brisbane

The Catholic Leader acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the First Peoples of this country and especially acknowledge the traditional owners on whose lands we live and work throughout the Catholic Archdiocese of Brisbane.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader

0
    0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyChoose another Subscription
    Continue Shopping