Skip to content
The Catholic Leader
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
The Catholic Leader
No Result
View All Result
Home Features

Surrogacy leads to confusion

byStaff writers
31 January 2010
Reading Time: 4 mins read
AA

Tragedy: “How have we become so remote from humanity that we cannot see the innocence, pure dignity, and pure design of such an infant and not be moved to horror and outrage…”

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

embryo cells

Queensland Bioethics Centre director RAY CAMPBELL, who is a spokesman for Brisbane archdiocese matters of bioethics, explains the archdiocese’s concerns about the surrogacy legislation to be considered by the Queensland Parliament

TOWARDS the end of last year the Queensland Government introduced its Surrogacy Bill into State Parliament. It will probably be debated in early February.

The new bill should be of concern to all Queenslanders. It does much more than decriminalise surrogacy.

The bill redefines the meaning of parenthood, creating a legal construct completely divorced from biological realities.

Altruistic surrogacy is where one woman (the surrogate) bears a child (of which she may or may not be the genetic mother) with the intention of handing the child over to a commissioning person or persons (who may or may not be genetically related to the child) after the birth of the child without being paid a fee, although she may receive payment for “expenses”.

Presently this is a criminal offence in Queensland.

Brisbane archdiocese and many others supported the decriminalisation of surrogacy as far as removing criminal sanctions against the surrogate mother and the commissioning parents, while maintaining other sanctions to discourage surrogacy.

The new legislation decriminalises and seeks to regulate so-called “altruistic surrogacy”, but “commercial surrogacy” remains illegal.

This division is somewhat artificial.

Related Stories

Cleanup begins after floodwaters swamp South East Queensland again

Angel’s Kitchen serves hot meals to the hungry in Southport

The Church canonises 10 new saints who shared God’s love

It is inevitable that IVF services will be involved in assisting surrogacy.

I have not heard any of them declare that they will offer such services for free or at cost.

pregnant womanFor IVF services surrogacy is a commercial transaction.

On this matter you could argue that the legislation is discriminatory.

It allows those who assist in the begetting of the child through surrogacy to profit from their actions, but the woman who carries the child is not allowed to profit.

All surrogacy is disrespectful of the dignity of the child in his or her origins and has the potential to be the source of confusion of personal identity for the child in the future.

The Government has maintained the situation that a surrogacy agreement is not legally binding.

To this extent it seems to recognise that surrogacy is not a good thing. But it then introduces a range of measures to support people who have entered into such an arrangement.

By regulating surrogacy the Government approves of it and in so doing creates a system which will lead to more children being subjected to the confusion of surrogacy.

According to the legislation any person, regardless of relationship status, will potentially be able to enter into a surrogacy arrangement.

This means:

  • A child can be conceived using “donor gametes” such that none of the contracting parties have a genetic relationship to the child. A child could in effect have six parents – the genetic parents, the surrogate mother and her partner, and the commissioning “parents” who become the social parents.
  • A single person could be the commissioning parent.
  • De facto couples can be the commissioning parents.
  • Same-sex couples (male/male or female/female) could be the commissioning “parents”.
  • The commissioning parents will apply for the transfer of legal parentage which will result in them being recognised as the legal parents of the child. Parenthood is completely divorced from biological reality and made into a purely legal construct determined by the desires of adults.

The proposed legislation will deny to some children their fundamental rights to both a father and a mother and to know and be reared within his or her own biological family.

The importance of our biological origins, embodied in our genetic connections to earlier generations, is so well attested today that it is difficult to imagine why a government would produce legislation which is so dismissive of this reality.

We are more than the sum total of our genes, but our biological origins are important for our identity.

We have had years of experience of adopted children seeking out knowledge of their biological parents.

We have had the experience of millions of people tracking down their genealogies, wanting to trace their biological origins.

We have had the experience of children conceived from anonymous sperm donation testifying to the hole that they felt in their lives when they discovered the truth of their origins.

We have had the experience of the “stolen generations”.

You would think that we would learn from the past. But it seems not.

The bill also allows for the creation of a new class of child, the legally fatherless child and the legally motherless child.

The legislation is clearly about satisfying the desires of adults.

Whenever the term the “best interests of the child” is used by people supporting this legislation it really means the best interests of the child “after” the interests of the adults have been served.

It is difficult to understand why well meaning politicians are so blind to what they are doing in this legislation.

Christine Whipp, a donor-conceived child, puts the question well:

“I could not understand how the pioneers of AID [artificial insemination with donor sperm] had thought it possible to translate the breeding principles of animal husbandry into the more complex arena of human relationships and ‘family building’. Why should the pain of childlessness of one generation take precedence over the needs and rights of the next?” (‘Worrying the wound: the hidden scars of donor conception‘, in ‘Who am I? Experiences of donor conception‘, by Dr Alexina McWhinnie (Warwickshire: Idreos Education Trust, 2006) p.21)

The concerns which the Government has regarding children who are unfortunately born through surrogacy can be addressed in other ways.

There is no need for this deconstruction of the family.

We need people to contact their local state member to express their concerns regarding this legislation.

[divider]

ShareTweet
Previous Post

A film aimed at adults

Next Post

Surrogacy law concerns raised

Staff writers

Related Posts

Cleanup begins after floodwaters swamp South East Queensland again

Cleanup begins after floodwaters swamp South East Queensland again

16 May 2022
Angel’s Kitchen serves hot meals to the hungry in Southport
QLD

Angel’s Kitchen serves hot meals to the hungry in Southport

16 May 2022
The Church canonises 10 new saints who shared God’s love
Vatican

The Church canonises 10 new saints who shared God’s love

16 May 2022
Next Post

Surrogacy law concerns raised

Calling for help

Pray 2010 gathers momentum

Popular News

  • Here are the stories of 10 new saints being canonised this Sunday

    Here are the stories of 10 new saints being canonised this Sunday

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Hearts ‘fused’ together living their vocation

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Church canonises 10 new saints who shared God’s love

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Queensland election: The pro-life political parties committed to abortion law reforms

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Link between porn and partner violence growing

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Search our job finder
No Result
View All Result

Latest News

Cleanup begins after floodwaters swamp South East Queensland again

Cleanup begins after floodwaters swamp South East Queensland again

by Mark Bowling
16 May 2022
0

LAIDLEY parishioners in the Lockyer Valley west of Brisbane are relieved after floodwater rose to the top...

Angel’s Kitchen serves hot meals to the hungry in Southport

Angel’s Kitchen serves hot meals to the hungry in Southport

16 May 2022
The Church canonises 10 new saints who shared God’s love

The Church canonises 10 new saints who shared God’s love

16 May 2022
Hearts ‘fused’ together living their vocation

Hearts ‘fused’ together living their vocation

15 May 2022
Link between porn and partner violence growing

Link between porn and partner violence growing

14 May 2022

Never miss a story. Sign up to the Weekly Round-Up
eNewsletter now to receive headlines directly in your email.

Sign up to eNews
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe

The Catholic Leader is an Australian award-winning Catholic newspaper that has been published by the Archdiocese of Brisbane since 1929. Our journalism seeks to provide a full, accurate and balanced Catholic perspective of local, national and international news while upholding the dignity of the human person.

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader
Accessibility Information | Privacy Policy | Archdiocese of Brisbane

The Catholic Leader acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the First Peoples of this country and especially acknowledge the traditional owners on whose lands we live and work throughout the Catholic Archdiocese of Brisbane.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader

0
    0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyChoose another Subscription
    Continue Shopping