Skip to content
The Catholic Leader
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute
No Result
View All Result
The Catholic Leader
No Result
View All Result
Home Features

Children are God’s gift and not a right

byStaff writers
13 July 2008
Reading Time: 5 mins read
AA
family

Two synods: The Vatican has announced that the October synod on the family will be followed by another next year to draw up proposals.

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Surrogacy is under parliamentary review in Queensland. Director of Brisbane archdiocese’s Queensland Bioethics Centre RAY CAMPBELL explains the Church position on the issue 

THE Queensland State Parliament is holding an inquiry into the practice of surrogacy. The inquiry is considering whether surrogacy should be decriminalised and, if so, in what ways the Government should regulate the practice through legislation.

Surrogacy is proposed as a possible solution for some people who suffer from infertility. It is also being proposed as a way in which a same-sex couple might have a child which is genetically related to one of the couple.

For a married couple to discover that they are infertile is a tragic event.

Most couples who marry do so with the idea that at some stage they will have a family. When a couple find they are infertile a large part of what they had foreseen as their life-project together is shattered.

Some seek ways to get around their infertility through various means of assisted reproduction. The proposed option for some people is surrogacy.

But surrogacy goes against the nature of marriage itself.

Marriage is a permanent and exclusive communion of a man and a woman ordered towards their own well being and the procreation and upbringing of children.

Surrogacy introduces an outsider into the marriage covenant with the aim of producing and/or carrying a child who is not the fruit of the marital act of the couple.

Surrogacy “sets up to the detriment of families, a division between the physical, psychological and moral elements which constitute those families”. (Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Donum Vitae)

Related Stories

All Catholics invited to pray rosary for peace with Pope Francis next Tuesday

Gunmen kidnap two Catholic priests in Nigeria

Ethiopian cardinal brings sense of gratitude to Australia

In so doing it acts against the marital good.

Marriage involves a commitment of the married couple to each other. Part of that commitment is to have children only with one’s spouse.

By breaking this commitment surrogacy undermines both the commissioning couple’s marriage and the surrogate’s marriage if she is married.

As well as the nature of marriage itself, in considering surrogacy the Government should bear in mind “the best interests of the child”, in other words, what is the best for a child a couple might have.

No-one has a right to a child. A child is a subject of human rights, not an object of someone else’s rights.

A child is entitled to be respected as equal in dignity to his or her parents, including in his or her origins.

However, in a surrogacy agreement, whether it is commercial or not, the child is the object of an arrangement aimed at fulfilling the needs of the commissioning parents.

The child to this extent is commodified.

In most cases of surrogacy the surrogate mother not only carries the child in her womb, she also supplies the egg, ie she is the mother of child.

Conception usually takes place through artificial insemination with the sperm of the husband of the commissioning parents.

The child is created in circumstances of ambiguous parenthood in which a child may have a matrix of parents – social mother, gestational mother, genetic mother, social father, genetic father and the men (if any) who partner the gestational and genetic mother.

The experience of children whose genetic origins are so confused is sometimes referred to as “genealogical bewilderment”.

We have some knowledge of this from the experience of adult donor conceived children. These are children who were conceived from donated sperm.

More and more adult children conceived through donor insemination are telling their stories of the effects this ambiguous parenthood has had on them, in particular their disturbed sense of identity.

In surrogacy, adults knowingly set about to create a situation where the child’s genetic parentage, gestational parentage and social parentage will be discontinuous.

Once known to the child (and often suspected even when not told), the child’s personal identity is called into question.

Personal identity is a complex reality, but it certainly includes our genetic heritage.

There are ethical issues surrounding the surrogate mother as well.

“Altruistic” means to have regard for the well being of others.

It is hard to see how it can be said that the gestational mother is motivated by the well being of the child.

It would appear that her altruism is supposedly directed to the well being of the commissioning parents. But how does one establish that this is the motivation?

The surrogate could be acting from a low self-esteem and a desire to please others as did Elizabeth Kane, the first legal surrogate mother in the United States.

A prospective surrogate could also be acting out of guilt after an earlier termination of pregnancy.

Or the surrogate might simply be someone who “enjoys” being pregnant. Or the surrogate herself might be a victim of emotional exploitation.

No-one can ensure that the surrogacy arrangement is “altruistic”, and it can never be “altruistic” vis-à-vis the child.

Even if the surrogate freely enters into the arrangement still,

“surrogate motherhood represents an objective failure to meet the obligations of maternal love, of conjugal fidelity and of responsible motherhood; it offends the dignity and the right of the child to be conceived, carried in the womb, brought into the world and brought up by his own parents …” (Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Donum Vitae)

Finally, as regards the commissioning parents – the sad fact is that surrogacy cannot give them the only child they can legitimately hope for: the child who is the fruit and embodiment of their marital love because conceived in their marital embrace.

Surrogacy gives them “second best”, and should anyone wish that for a child?

The first question the parliamentary inquiry is asked to consider is whether altruistic surrogacy should be decriminalised in Queensland. (Queensland is the only state where it is a criminal offence for the surrogate mother and commissioning parents.)

The criminal law cannot be used to enforce all morally good actions, for example conceiving a child outside of marriage is immoral, but not a criminal offence.

Sometimes making something a criminal offence can lead to greater evil.

This could be the case with surrogacy.

If someone has entered into a surrogacy arrangement and is threatened with exposure and a criminal sanction she may resort to an abortion in order to “destroy the evidence”.

The Australian Catholic Bishops Conference has consistently argued against surrogacy but not for the criminalisation of “altruistic” surrogacy as such.

Instead the bishops argued for a range of other measures to seek to discourage surrogacy.

I would follow the example of the Catholic bishops and argue to decriminalise surrogacy as regards the surrogate mother and the commissioning parents.

However I would recommend putting in place other measures to discourage surrogacy. Hence I argue that surrogacy “contracts” should remain null and void, ie they should be unenforceable.

Furthermore the Government should seek to discourage surrogacy by making it an offence to: advertise or promote surrogacy arrangements; receive a fee in connection with professional services to assist surrogacy (this would include IVF procedures); Medicare should not fund medical procedures involving surrogacy arrangements; in the event that surrogacy occurs the woman who gives birth should be recognised as the mother of the child.

In the case of the birth of a child through surrogacy the situation should be treated much the same as a child who is born outside of marriage.

The woman who gives birth should be regarded as the mother.

If she does not want to keep the child then the principle of the child’s best interests should be used to ensure that a decision about social parenthood is determined not by a surrogacy contract but according to a judicial decision in the child’s favour.

ShareTweet
Previous Post

THE INCREDIBLE HULK – Hulk entertains in big screen return

Next Post

Queenslanders share their faith with the world

Staff writers

Related Posts

Vatican

All Catholics invited to pray rosary for peace with Pope Francis next Tuesday

27 May 2022
Gunmen kidnap two Catholic priests in Nigeria
World

Gunmen kidnap two Catholic priests in Nigeria

27 May 2022
Ethiopian cardinal brings sense of gratitude to Australia
Australia

Ethiopian cardinal brings sense of gratitude to Australia

26 May 2022
Next Post

Queenslanders share their faith with the world

Youth pilgrims light up Sydney with their faith

Maronite Catholics rejoice

Popular News

  • Blessed Sacrament desecrated in robbery of sacred vessels at Canberra church

    Blessed Sacrament desecrated in robbery of sacred vessels at Canberra church

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Br Alan Moss remembered for a life of faith and learning

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Christian Brothers’ community mourn the passing of Brother Tony White

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • All Catholics invited to pray rosary for peace with Pope Francis next Tuesday

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Gunmen kidnap two Catholic priests in Nigeria

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Search our job finder
No Result
View All Result

Latest News

Vatican

All Catholics invited to pray rosary for peace with Pope Francis next Tuesday

by Staff writers
27 May 2022
0

By Catholic News Agency THE Vatican is inviting Catholics to join Pope Francis in praying the rosary...

Gunmen kidnap two Catholic priests in Nigeria

Gunmen kidnap two Catholic priests in Nigeria

27 May 2022
Ethiopian cardinal brings sense of gratitude to Australia

Ethiopian cardinal brings sense of gratitude to Australia

26 May 2022
Blessed Sacrament desecrated in robbery of sacred vessels at Canberra church

Blessed Sacrament desecrated in robbery of sacred vessels at Canberra church

26 May 2022
Pope Francis – ‘My heart is broken’ over Texas elementary school shooting

Pope Francis – ‘My heart is broken’ over Texas elementary school shooting

26 May 2022

Never miss a story. Sign up to the Weekly Round-Up
eNewsletter now to receive headlines directly in your email.

Sign up to eNews
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe

The Catholic Leader is an Australian award-winning Catholic newspaper that has been published by the Archdiocese of Brisbane since 1929. Our journalism seeks to provide a full, accurate and balanced Catholic perspective of local, national and international news while upholding the dignity of the human person.

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader
Accessibility Information | Privacy Policy | Archdiocese of Brisbane

The Catholic Leader acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the First Peoples of this country and especially acknowledge the traditional owners on whose lands we live and work throughout the Catholic Archdiocese of Brisbane.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • QLD
    • Australia
    • Regional
    • Education
    • World
    • Vatican
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Life
    • Family
    • Relationships
    • Faith
  • Culture
  • People
  • Subscribe
  • Jobs
  • Contribute

Copyright © All Rights Reserved The Catholic Leader

0
    0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyChoose another Subscription
    Continue Shopping