Monday, July 6, 2020
Username Password
Home » Arts & Entertainment » Overcoming hatred and vengeance
Free digital edition during COVID-19

Overcoming hatred and vengeance

THE RAILWAY MAN: Starring Colin Firth, Nicole Kidman, Jeremy Irvine, Stellan Skarsgard. Directed by Jonathan Teplitzky. 116 minutes. Rated M (Mature themes and violence).

Reviewed by Fr Peter Malone MSC

THIS is a film that can be recommended – with the caution that it has many harrowing moments.

The advertising for The Railway Man seems to indicate that this is a film about the Thai-Burma railway during World War II. It is, but it is much more than that.

The main action takes place during the 1980s.

The film opens with a group of ageing former soldiers sitting in a veterans’ club in a Scottish town by the sea.

Colin Firth in a scene from The Railway Man

Reliving past: Colin Firth gives one of his best performances in The Railway Man

One of the characters is Eric Lomax, a veteran of the Thai-Burma railway. But, he is also a railway man in the present, with a love for trains, and a seemingly encyclopaedic knowledge of the intricacies of British rail, stations, times, timetables, possibilities for connections.

He suddenly rushes out of the club telling the other men that he has a puzzle to solve.

There is a flashback to one of his trips, his missing a connection but working out another, and explaining this to the rather quiet and bemused woman who is sitting opposite him in the train. They begin a conversation, he giving information of the history of the town about which she is talking. There is something of an attraction but he has to hurry from the train for his connection.

He realises later that he is drawn to her and calculates that he would be able to meet the train she had told him about at Edinburgh station.

There is an attraction, love and a wedding.

In the early months of their marriage, Eric has a nightmare, his adult self back in the prison camp, being hustled into the black hole.

He wakes screaming which terrifies his wife, Patti. But he cannot communicate anything of his war experiences to her.

The screenplay, based on Eric Lomax’s book about his experiences, introduces one of his friends from the camp, Finlay, who is able to take her through his version and memories of the experiences.

This begins a series of flashbacks to Eric during the fall of Singapore, the Japanese round-up, the cramming of prisoners on the trains, arrival at the site of the building of the railway as well as many scenes in the camp, the brutal work in the heat, the humiliation of the officers, the beatings.

Colin Firth and Nicole Kidman in a scene from The Railway Man

Colin Firth and Nicole Kidman in a scene from The Railway Man

He has developed a hatred of the Japanese, a brooding hatred which he shares with Finlay. And the question is raised: can Eric go through life with the bitterness and the hatred?

The latter part of the film deals with Eric and his emotional dilemmas in the 1980s, including a visit to the site of the camp and an encounter with the translator in the camp.

Because the Thai-Burma railway played a significant role in Australian involvement in World War II, the film is of particular interest.

But its theme of cruelty and torture, its theme of bitterness and feelings of vengeance, its theme of asking when hatred must stop and reconciliation be fostered, make it a moving and significant film.

Fr Peter Malone MSC is an associate of the Australian Catholic Office for Film and Broadcasting.

Catholic Church Insurance

Comments are closed.

Scroll To Top